When it comes to thickening vocal tracks, there’s a crucial distinction that separates professional-sounding productions from amateur ones: understanding the difference between vocal doubles and vocal duplicates. While both techniques can add width and depth to a vocal, they work in fundamentally different ways and produce vastly different results.
What Are Vocal Duplicates?
Vocal duplicates are exact copies of the original vocal track. When you duplicate a track in your DAW, you’re creating a perfect clone of the same audio file. Every breath, every pitch fluctuation, every timing nuance is identical.
Characteristics of Duplicates:
- Exact copy of the original performance
- When panned, creates a wider stereo image
- Increases perceived volume at the center when both are centered
- Can be processed with different effects (chorus, delay, pitch shifting)
- Subject to phase cancellation when summed to mono
Common Uses:
- Creating artificial width through stereo spreading
- Building harmonizers or pitch-shifted layers
- Adding effects to one copy while keeping the other dry
- Quick stereo widening (though not the most natural approach)
What Are Vocal Doubles?
Vocal doubles (also called double-tracking) involve recording a completely separate performance of the same vocal part. The singer performs the line again, trying to match the original as closely as possible, but inevitably creating natural variations in timing, pitch, and tone.
Characteristics of Doubles:
- Separate, unique performance
- Natural timing and pitch variations
- Creates genuine thickness and depth
- More forgiving when summed to mono
- Sounds fuller and more professional
- Harder to achieve (requires another take)
The Magic of Imperfection:
The slight differences between takes—microsecond timing variations, subtle pitch differences, and tonal inconsistencies—are what create the lush, three-dimensional quality that defines professional vocal production. These imperfections prevent the phase issues that plague duplicates and create a natural chorus effect.
The Phase Problem with Duplicates
When identical audio signals are combined, they can experience phase cancellation. If you duplicate a vocal, pan both copies hard left and right, and then sum to mono (which happens on phones, some Bluetooth speakers, and many playback systems), the signals can partially or completely cancel each other out, leaving you with a thin, hollow, or even silent vocal.
Doubles, with their natural variations, are much more resilient to mono compatibility issues. The slight differences prevent complete phase cancellation, ensuring your vocal remains present and full on all playback systems.
When to Use Each Technique
Use Vocal Doubles When:
- You want authentic thickness and depth
- The vocal is a lead or prominent element
- You have time for multiple takes
- Mono compatibility is important
- You’re going for a professional, polished sound
Use Vocal Duplicates When:
- You need quick stereo widening
- You’re creating special effects
- You want to apply different processing to layers
- You’re building harmonies artificially
- The vocal is a background element or effect
How to Record Great Vocal Doubles
- Listen carefully to the original take between recordings
- Match the performance as closely as possible while staying natural
- Record at least two doubles (one for each side) for maximum effect
- Don’t overdo it — slight variations are good, but wildly different performances won’t gel
- Pan them strategically — typically 50-80% left and right, leaving the lead centered
Hybrid Approaches
Many professional productions use both techniques strategically. You might have a lead vocal down the center, hard-panned doubles for thickness, and then duplicates with subtle chorus effects pushed further back in the mix for additional texture. The key is understanding what each technique brings to the table and using them intentionally.
Conclusion
While duplicates have their place in music production, nothing beats the natural thickness and professional sound of properly recorded vocal doubles. The time investment in capturing additional performances pays dividends in the finished product. Understanding when and how to use each technique will elevate your vocal productions and ensure they translate well across all playback systems.
The next time you’re tempted to just duplicate and pan, consider taking the time to track real doubles. Your ears—and your listeners—will thank you.
If you interested in mixing and mastering services make sure to reach out or you can fine my vocal presets here.